Why an Amateur’s Attempt at Fraud Failed

Barry Zalma
Nov 30, 2023

Read the full article at https://lnkd.in/g9Ppqek4 and see the full video at https://lnkd.in/gWW8WSCE and at https://lnkd.in/g9eKjimm and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4650 posts.

Post 4679

This is a fictionalized true crime story of Insurance Fraud explaining why Insurance Fraud is a “Heads I Win, Tails You Lose” situation for Insurers. The story is presented to help a reader to Understand How Insurance Fraud in America is Costing Everyone who Buys Insurance Thousands of Dollars Every year and Why Insurance Fraud is Safer and More Profitable for the ­­­Perpetrators than any Other Crime.

The insured was a poet. Before immigrating from Soviet Armenia, he was a member in good standing at the Armenian Poets Union. They paid him for his work five hundred rubles a month.

He lived in the capital city of Yerevan in the shadow of Mount Ararat. He, like all Soviet citizens, before the fall of the Soviet Union, supplemented his income by buying and selling in the black market. He specialized in jewelry and diamonds.

By 1977 he had amassed, off the pain and suffering of others, over 300 carats of diamonds and diamond jewelry. Most of the diamonds were old mine cut, popular in Russia in the 1890’s, but out of date. The wealth he had amassed frightened him. He knew that eventually the Soviet Police would catch him and send him to a Gulag. He was committing the most heinous of Soviet crimes: he was a successful entrepreneur.

He went to the American Consulate and got a visa as a refugee. He had convinced the American Consulate the Soviet Government was censoring his poetry. He wanted freedom to write.

Poetry is not an essential industry. The Soviet Government agreed to his immigration. He came directly to Los Angeles and settled in the Armenian community in the hills of Glendale, California. He brought with him all but twenty carats of the diamonds. He needed to use some of his 300 carats to bribe Soviet Customs Officials to get safely out of the country.

For many years he and his family lived by selling the diamonds at auctions. He continued to write poetry but there was no market for Armenian poetry in the United States. The few Armenian language newspapers would publish his poems but could not pay him.

Eventually his inventory of fine jewelry began to shrink. He had learned to enjoy living in the luxury the diamond sales had brought him. He didn’t know how to earn money to support himself in America. He did not want to return to Soviet Armenia to be a salaried poet.

At a social gathering at the Armenian church after services he expressed his concerns to an acquaintance who ran an art gallery. The gallery owner had been in the United States longer than the poet. He knew how trusting Americans were. He knew that Americans believed what they were told until proved otherwise. He understood that Americans took seriously their belief that everyone was innocent until proven guilty. He explained to his poet friend how he could easily make enough money to support his family comfortably for the rest of his life. The gallery owner told the poet he would rent him a portion of his art gallery to open a jewelry store. The poet only needed to buy an insurance policy insuring against loss of an inventory of his jewelry. The insurer would not ask him before issuing a policy to prove he had any jewelry but would take his word.

The poet was incredulous.

“Won’t they want to see the jewelry?”

“No. They insured my art gallery without ever sending anyone to look at the paintings. If they do send someone out just tell them the jewelry is in your safety deposit box. Tell them you feared bringing it out until you had insurance. You can put in showcases the jewelry you do have to make it look like a legitimate jewelry store.”

The next day Poetry Jewelry was born. The poet immediately applied for insurance. He filled out the application form honestly stating that he had been in the jewelry business for ten years buying and selling jewelry from his home. This was his first attempt at a retail business. He had never had a loss. He had never had an insurance policy canceled. He had over a million dollars in inventory.

The insurer took the risk without any questions. The security and safes were proper. The premium would be paid in full since the poet had obtained independent premium financing through his broker and only needed to pay 20% of the annual premium.

The insurer issued a policy that requested an immediate inspection of the premises. The inspector visited the premises, saw immediately that it was not as represented and advised the company to cancel. They did.

The insured went to a new broker. The new insurer did not require an inspection of the premises by anyone other than the broker. It issued a million dollar policy. Two weeks later, before the insurer could change its mind, the poet’s oldest son locked the poet and his mother, the poet’s wife, and the gallery owner in the small four by four foot bathroom. The son then took home all the inventory of Poetry Jewelers.

The three people locked in the bathroom waited ten minutes to make sure the oldest son had driven away and then pushed the holdup button secreted in the bathroom because it is common for thieves to lock jewelry store owners in the bathroom. The three captives also pounded on the wall to gain the attention of the restaurant owner next door. The police were called and broke the door down to free the poet, his wife and the gallery owner.

The loss exceeded a million dollars. The poet thanked God that they were insured.

Their million dollar fraud would have been successful but for an unusual coincidence. The insurer hired as its adjuster the same firm that had inspected the store for the first insurer. The adjuster remembered the insured. He knew that the prior insurer had canceled. He knew when the poet told him that the policy was his first ever that he was lying. The adjuster knew when the insured told him that his inventory was a million dollars he was lying.

The adjuster gathered the evidence together and presented it to the insurer. The insurer decided to rescind the policy and deny the claim.

The insured and the gallery owner, his mentor, were shocked. They did not give up. They became more aggressive. They retained a lawyer. The lawyer immediately filed suit in U.S. District Court for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing and made claim for fifty million dollars over the one million dollar claim. The insurer was confident it was right. It would not allow an insurance fraud to go forward. It would fight the poet through trial. It was, unusually for American insurers, dedicated to its cause.

The insurance company spared nothing. Its lawyers deposed every person who had any connection with the poet. The deposition of the poet lasted for three days. Each member of the family was deposed. Paralegals poured over every word of the transcripts and found conflicting testimony. The insurer obtained documentary evidence from every possible location except Yerevan, Soviet Armenia. The lawyers spent weeks preparing for trial. The poet was unprepared. His family was unprepared. They expected, regardless of the evidence they presented, that the jury would hate the insurance company and punish it.

At trial, although well-rehearsed, the poet’s lies began to compound. The testimony of the inspector established the inventory was not there at the time of the inspection. The insured did not have a safety deposit box and therefore could not even prove the existence of a box to hold the jewelry he claimed he had. Under cross-examination the poet’s son’s testimony became confused. The judge took over the cross- examination and, unable to answer confidently, the poet’s son broke down and cried on the stand. Lies were admitted.

After five days of trial with testimony from nine in the morning until six every night, the jury went off to deliberate. The jury returned with its verdict in forty-five minutes after spending thirty minutes to pick a foreman. The verdict was for the defense. The jury was convinced that the poet had presented a fraudulent claim and that the insurance company had properly rescinded the policy.

The result was unusual. The cost was enormous. The investigation cost, court costs, expert witness fees and attorneys’ fees exceeded $500,000. The insurer defeated the claim for one million dollars in lost jewelry and fifty million dollars in punitive damages.

The word went out. This insurance company fights. Do not insure with them.

The insurer saved more than the payment of the poet’s claim. It saved all the other fraudulent claims that would have been presented had they not fought. The poet paid nothing to his lawyer who took the case on a contingency basis. He continued living off the jewelry he brought from Soviet Armenia.

The poet’s attempt at insurance fraud failed. He learned a lesson about American jurisprudence. He would only make claims against insurance companies willing to insure him after he honestly reports his earlier attempts at fraud. He would not fake a fraudulent claim. He was lucky he was not referred to the U.S. Attorney by the trial judge.

This blog was adapted from my book Insurance Fraud Costs Everyone Amazon.com.

(c) 2023 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.

Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.

Subscribe to Excellence in Claims Handling at locals.com at https://zalmaoninsurance.locals.com/subscribe or at substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/publish/post/107007808

Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01

Follow me on LinkedIn: http://www.linkedin.com/comm/mynetwork/discovery-see-all...

Daily articles are published at https://zalma.substack.com.

Go to the podcast Zalma On Insurance at https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/barry-zalma/support; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – http://zalma.com/blog/insurance-claims-library.

Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos. Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://lnkd.in/gV9QJYH.

Go to the Insurance Claims Library – Go to Newsbreak.com https://lnkd.in/g8azKc34