Insured Convicted of Fraud But Still Sought UIM Benefits
Read the full article at https://lnkd.in/giAZUjCM and see the full video at https://lnkd.in/gZ9EQRhk and at https://lnkd.in/gk78YptC and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4250 posts.
Posted on July 8, 2022 by Barry Zalma
See the full video at https://rumble.com/v1bb909-chutzpah-admit-fraud-and-claims-fraud-exclusion-ambiguous.html and at
“Chutzpah” is a Yiddish term meaning “unmitigated gall” where, for example, a defendant convicted of murdering his parents asks for clemency because he is an orphan.
Kevin Muir made a claim for underinsured motorist benefits after being injured in an auto accident that fit the definition of Chutzpah. His insurance company denied the claim because Muir had admittedly previously made fraudulent statements in an effort to obtain personal injury protection benefits related to the same accident and was convicted of a crime relating to the claim. Although the policy, like all insurance policies, excluded claims related to fraud, Muir still sued the insurance company after it denied his claim. The insurer filed a motion for summary judgment and the district court dismissed Muir’s lawsuit.
In Kevin Muir v. Cincinnati Insurance Company, 2022 UT App 80, No. 20210289-CA, Court of Appeals of Utah (June 24, 2022) the Court of Appeals found the fraud exclusion clear and unambiguous.
BACKGROUND
Muir is listed as a “covered driver” under an auto insurance policy (the Policy) issued to him by Cincinnati Insurance Company (Cincinnati). The Policy provided several types of coverage, including liability, personal injury protection (PIP), uninsured/underinsured motorist (UIM), and collision.
In 2017, Muir was riding as a passenger in a vehicle that was rear-ended by another vehicle. Muir suffered injuries and received $25,000 in damages from each of the two drivers’ insurance companies-amounts that represented the policy limits of those policies. Cincinnati also paid out PIP benefits to Muir under the Policy.
THE FRAUD
In connection with his PIP claim, Muir “stated that he was not working due to the injuries he sustained,” but this statement was false: Muir was, in fact, “working as a self-employed truck driver.” As a result of his false statement, Muir “was charged criminally with insurance fraud and entered ‘no contest’ pleas to reduced Class A misdemeanors.”
THE CLAIM
Muir subsequently made a demand for UIM benefits under the Policy. However, Cincinnati denied coverage, relying on the Policy’s fraud exclusion, which reads:
‘We’ do not provide coverage for any ‘covered person’ who has made fraudulent statements or engaged in fraudulent conduct in connection with any accident or loss for which coverage is sought under this policy.
Following this denial, Muir sued Cincinnati for breach of contract and breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment on the question of whether the Policy’s fraud exclusion precluded Muir’s claim for UIM benefits.
The district court granted Cincinnati’s motion and denied Muir’s.
ANALYSIS
Muir claimed that the Policy’s fraud exclusion was ambiguous and asked the court to construe the ambiguity in his favor.
The Court of Appeals noted that an insurance policy is merely a contract between the insured and the insurer and is construed pursuant to the same rules applied to ordinary contracts. An insurer may exclude from coverage certain losses by using language which clearly and unmistakably communicates to the insured the specific circumstances under which the expected coverage will not be provided.
The Policy contains a fraud exclusion that bars coverage when a claimant makes a fraudulent statement in connection with any accident or loss for which coverage is sought. Muir acknowledged that he made fraudulent statements in securing PIP benefits in connection with the accident in question but argued that those fraudulent statements should not negate his claim for UIM benefits.
The fraud exclusion is contained in the “General Provisions” section of the Policy, not within any specific coverage provision, so the exclusion is applicable to all types of coverage provided by the Policy. The inclusion of the word “accident” in the fraud clause links the misrepresentation to the accident in question, not just to the coverage sought, and makes Muir’s preferred reading of the provision unreasonable, especially given Muir’s admission that his “fraudulent conduct was indeed ‘connected’ to the accident” at issue.
The accident for which Muir sought UIM coverage is the same accident for which he made fraudulent statements in seeking PIP coverage. And the Policy precludes coverage sought in connection with any accident for which a covered person has made fraudulent statements.
The Court of Appeal, therefore, agreed with the district court’s determination that Cincinnati was, as a matter of law, within its rights under the Policy to deny Muir’s claim for UIM coverage.
ZALMA OPINION
This case teaches that there is no such thing as a small or inconsequential fraud. The fraud language of the policy was clear and unambiguous as it applied to the entire policy. Muir fraudulently collected on his PIP claim when he succeeded in his attempt to defraud Cincinnati and was convicted criminally of the attempted fraudulent claim. His chutzpah in seeking UIM coverage under the same policy where he was, because of his fraud was unmitigated and not worthy of a law suit let alone an appeal. In fact, Cincinnati should seek to recover as restitution the money paid in PIP benefits.
(c) 2022 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Barry Zalma, Esq., CFE, now limits his practice to service as an insurance consultant specializing in insurance coverage, insurance claims handling, insurance bad faith and insurance fraud almost equally for insurers and policyholders. He practiced law in California for more than 44 years as an insurance coverage and claims handling lawyer and more than 54 years in the insurance business. He is available at http://www.zalma.com and [email protected].
Subscribe and receive videos limited to subscribers of Excellence in Claims Handling at locals.com https://zalmaoninsurance.locals.com/subscribe.
Subscribe to Excellence in Claims Handling at https://barryzalma.substack.com/welcome.
Write to Mr. Zalma at [email protected]; http://www.zalma.com; http://zalma.com/blog; daily articles are published at https://zalma.substack.com.
Go to the podcast Zalma On Insurance at https://anchor.fm/barry-zalma; Follow Mr. Zalma on Twitter at https://twitter.com/bzalma; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://zalma.com/blog/insurance-claims-library/
Insurance Expert May Not Testify to Speculative and Contains Unsupported Conclusions.
Posted on September 18, 2026 by Barry Zalma
See the full video at and at https://rumble.com/v7fmifw-expert-may-only-testify-to-what-experience-supports.html
In Michele A. Over, and The Estate Of Paul R. Over v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, and State Farm Fire And Casualty Company, Civil Action No. 23-cv-02243-PAB-STV, United States District Court, D. Colorado (September 14, 2026) Michele and Paul Over sued State Farm Fire and State Farm Auto over hail-damage and stolen-vehicle claims.
The operative dispute concerned State Farm Auto’s motion to exclude or limit opinions from plaintiffs’ insurance-industry expert, Aaron Castillo. Castillo.
Law
The proponent of expert testimony must establish by a preponderance of the evidence that an expert is qualified and that the opinions are helpful, sufficiently grounded, and reliably derived and applied. Experience-based opinions must explain how the...
150 Months in Prison for Tax Fraud
Post 4846
Posted on September 17, 2026 by Barry Zalma
See the full video at https://lnkd.in/g8rh3JBX and https://lnkd.in/gmkdy-9C, In United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, Nos. 25-10609, 25-10611, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit (September 9, 2026) the Eleventh Circuit affirmed all challenged convictions, the 150-month aggregate sentence, and the challenged $4,123,474.55 restitution award.
FACTS
In United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, Nos. 25-10609, 25-10611, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit (September 9, 2026) the Eleventh Circuit affirmed all challenged convictions, the 150-month aggregate sentence, and the challenged $4,123,474.55 restitution award.
FACTS
Thomas Addaquay controlled United Consolidated Accounting and Business Services (UC), nominally a check-cashing business.
The government proved a three-stage tax-refund scheme that converted the resulting refund checks into usable funds through ...
Major Fraud Perpetrator Asserts Fifth Amendment Privilege to Avoid Prosecution
Post 5489
Posted on September 14, 2026 by Barry Zalma
Fraudster Refuses to Answer Questions About His Alleged Fraud
See the full video at https://lnkd.in/gvicAMDr and at https://lnkd.in/gvicAMDr
In Great American Insurance Co. v. Gemstone Property Management, LLC, et al., No. 23-cv-9100 (LJL), United States District Court, S.D. New York (September 8, 2026) Great American Insurance Company alleged that it was defrauded through a scheme in which Subin Associates, LLP recruited individuals to stage construction-site injuries, arranged unnecessary medical treatment and litigation funding, and pursued fraudulent personal-injury claims.
Luis Manuel Garcia Salcedo, resulted in a $6 million settlement. Non-party Jose Hernandez allegedly worked as an assistant manager at Subin, operated Hernandez Associates, and owned litigation-funding companies that shared office space with Subin and provided services to its clients.
After Great American ...
Claims of Res Judicata and Procedural Default Defeats Habeas
Post 5543
Posted on November 13, 2026 by Barry Zalma
A Health Insurance Fraud Conviction Rested On Knowingly Submitting Materially False Or Misleading Claim Information With Specific Intent To Defraud.
A Health Insurance Fraud Conviction Rested On Knowingly Submitting Materially False Or Misleading Claim Information With Specific Intent To Defraud.
In Tariq Mustafa Abdulaziz v. Commissioner Of Correction, No. CV 26-5002432-S, Superior Court of Connecticut, Judicial District of Tolland, Habeas Docket (October 29, 2026) Tariq Mustafa Abdulaziz submitted 114 claims for in-home, face-to-face services purportedly provided to thirty program participants during four one-week periods. The department paid Neurostrategies, Inc., $13,650.
FACTS
The defendant waived his right to a jury trial and elected a trial to the court, D'Addabbo, J. Trial occurred over the course of eight days in August, 2022. The state presented testimony from ten witnesses and introduced thirty-three exhibits into ...
Theft of Confidential Information
Post 4581
Posted on November 12, 2026 by Barry Zalma
In People Center, Inc. v. Deel, Inc., et al., No. 25-cv-02576-CRB (LJC), United States District Court, N.D. California (November 7, 2026) People Center, doing business as Rippling, and Deel compete in payroll and human-resource management software. Rippling alleges that Deel and its executives recruited Rippling employee Keith O’Brien, based in Ireland, to disclose confidential information and trade secrets.
THE IRISH SUIT
Rippling sued O’Brien in Ireland and Deel in the United States. O’Brien subsequently retained separate counsel, supplied an affidavit describing the alleged espionage, and entered into a Cooperation Agreement with Rippling. In exchange for his cooperation, Rippling agreed to provide financial assistance, indemnification, and conditional dismissal of the Irish proceedings. The agreement also permitted renewed proceedings or a monetary judgment upon a material breach.
The Irish proceedings against O’Brien were dismissed...
A Proposed Amended Complaint That Includes New Factual Allegations to Remedy Pleading Deficiencies
Posted on November 11, 2026 by Barry Zalma
After Dismissal Fraud Victim May Amend Complaint After Dismissal
Post 4580
If A Proposed Amendment Is Not Clearly Futile, Then Denial Of Leave To Amend Is Improper
In John Hancock Life & Health Insurance Company v. Caring Connections LLC, Arthur Feldheim, and Blime a/k/a Vera Feldheim, Civ. No. 25-7574 (MAS)(JBD), United States District Court, D. New Jersey (November 6, 2026) John Hancock sued Caring Connections LLC, Arthur Feldheim, and Blime a/k/a Vera Feldheim on June 5, 2025, asserting thirteen claims, including fraud, breach of contract, and aiding and abetting fraud.
On March 26, 2026, this Court entered an order granting Caring Connections’ motion to dismiss and granting in part and denying in part the Feldheims’ motion to dismiss. The dismissed claims were dismissed without prejudice, and John Hancock timely sought leave to amend.
They also argued that the New ...