An Umbrella Policy’s UM Cover is not Auto Insurance
Read the full article at https://lnkd.in/gzNfz7rb and see the full video at https://lnkd.in/gzmpz8aY and at https://lnkd.in/gZFsCJca and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4250 posts.
Posted on June 30, 2022 by Barry Zalma
Umbrella Insurance is Only Obligated After Underlying Insurance is Exhausted
See the full video at https://rumble.com/v1ag99d-an-umbrella-policys-um-cover-is-not-auto-insurance.html?mref=6zof&mrefc=2 and at
Anthony DeSmet appealed from the summary judgment granted to Scottsdale Insurance Company on his claim alleging that Scottsdale had acted in bad faith in refusing to fulfill its responsibilities under the excess uninsured-motorist coverage in its umbrella policy.
In Anthony Clarence Desmet v. Scottsdale Insurance Company, No. 21-6143, (D.C. No. 5:20-CV-00330-J) (W.D. Okla.), United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit (June 24, 2022) the Tenth Circuit was called Upon to Determine if an Umbrella Policy that provided excess uninsured motorist coverage was auto insurance.
Scottsdale, in its motion for summary judgment, invoked a provision in its policy that excused it from liability until DeSmet exhausted his uninsured-motorist coverage under his primary motor-vehicle liability policies. The USDC for the Western District of Oklahoma held that the exhaustion provision in Scottsdale’s policy was valid and enforceable and that even if it was not, Scottsdale’s reliance on the provision was not in bad faith.
BACKGROUND
On March 5, 2018, DeSmet suffered severe bodily injuries when his vehicle was rear-ended by a vehicle driven by William Akehurst. Akehurst’s only automobile-liability coverage was a policy issued by State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, which promptly paid its $50,000 policy limit. This was insufficient to fully cover DeSmet’s damages.
If the liability limits of a motor vehicle are less than the amount of the injured insured’s claim, that vehicle is classified as uninsured. Such tortfeasor drivers are commonly referred to as underinsured motorists.
At the time of the accident, DeSmet had three separate motor-vehicle liability policies covering several motor vehicles. Each policy provided $500,000 in uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.
In addition, DeSmet had an umbrella policy with Scottsdale. An umbrella policy is a type of “excess insurance policy.” Excess coverage is provided when, under the terms of the policy, the insurer is liable for a loss only after any primary coverage-other insurance-has been exhausted. The Scottsdale policy provided $2 million in excess liability coverage to supplement coverage provided in DeSmet’s automobile-liability and home-owner’s policies. An endorsement in the policy stated:
It is expressly agreed that liability shall attach to [Scottsdale] only after the insurers of the “underlying insurance” have paid or have been held liable to pay (whether collectible or not) the full amount of their respective uninsured motorists and/or underinsured motorists liability[.]
The term underlying insurance referred to existing motor vehicle liability policies carried by DeSmet that were listed in the Scottsdale policy’s Declarations.
Unhappy with the handling of his claim by one of his motor-vehicle liability insurers, DeSmet requested that Scottsdale “step down” and pay the claim itself. Scottsdale responded that per the terms of the policy, Scottsdale would pay only after the underlying insurance limits were exhausted.
DeSmet filed a petition in Oklahoma state court on March 3, 2020, alleging that Scottsdale’s conduct surrounding its refusal to pay amounted to a breach of its implied duty of good faith and fair dealing. The suit DeSmet filed included the following statement:
Plaintiff is not bringing an independent or separate cause of action for breach of contract, only the tort cause of action [for the breach of the implied duty of good faith and fair dealing]
At the time he sued DeSmet had received no payment on the uninsured/underinsured-motorist provisions of any of its three automobile-liability policies.
The district court ruled that Oklahoma caselaw was clear that the requirements of the uninsured-motorist statute did not apply to umbrella policies like the one issued by Scottsdale. It further held that because the underlying claims had not yet been paid at the time of the suit, there was no basis for DeSmet’s allegation that Scottsdale had been acting in bad faith and it granted Scottsdale’s motion for summary judgment.
DISCUSSION
To show bad faith it is not enough that an insurer resists or litigates a claim. There must be a clear showing that the insurer was acting unreasonably and in bad faith by withholding payment. Thus, DeSmet would need to show that Scottsdale had clearly violated its responsibilities under the umbrella policy; this is a standard he could not meet.
The Oklahoma Supreme Court has held that an insurer that provides uninsured-motorist coverage as required and governed by § 3636 cannot rely on a provision in its policy that permits withholding payment under the coverage until the insured has exhausted all other uninsured/underinsured-motorist coverage. See Mustain v. U.S. Fid. &Guar. Co., 925 P.2d 533, 534 (Okla. 1996). It ruled that “as between the insurer and its insured[, uninsured-motorist] insurance is primary coverage,” that is, “the insurer is liable without regard to any other insurance coverage available,” Equity Mut. Ins. Co., 747 P.2d at 954.
Unfortunately for DeSmet, § 3636 does not apply to the Scottsdale umbrella policy. The Oklahoma Supreme Court has repeatedly said that umbrella policies are not “motor vehicle liability policies” of the type governed by § 3636. The leading case is Moser v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., 731 P.2d 406 (Okla. 1986). The court responded that “[t]he uninsured motorist provisions [of § 3636] apply [only] to . . . automobile liability insurance policies . . . but not to ‘umbrella’ policies ….” Id. at 409 (emphasis added).
DeSmet does not contest that his policy with Scottsdale was an “umbrella” policy. Scottsdale was entitled to rely upon the Moser line of cases and was not acting in bad faith when it assumed the legitimacy of the uninsured-motorist provisions of its umbrella policy. As a result, the court affirmed the USDC’s grant of Scottsdale’s summary judgment.
ZALMA OPINION
I can understand Mr. DeSmet’s impatience with his auto insurer’s delay in paying his claim but that does allow him to sue his Umbrella insurer asking that it ignore the clear and unambiguous conditions of its policy rather than suing the auto insurers who have failed to pay his claim. Rather than act reasonably he sued Scottsdale and failed to sue those insurers who owed him and who had failed to pay. His actions were illogical and in light of Oklahoma Supreme Court precedent he wasted the court’s time.
(c) 2022 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Barry Zalma, Esq., CFE, now limits his practice to service as an insurance consultant specializing in insurance coverage, insurance claims handling, insurance bad faith and insurance fraud almost equally for insurers and policyholders. He practiced law in California for more than 44 years as an insurance coverage and claims handling lawyer and more than 54 years in the insurance business. He is available at http://www.zalma.com and [email protected].
Subscribe and receive videos limited to subscribers of Excellence in Claims Handling at locals.com https://zalmaoninsurance.locals.com/subscribe.
Subscribe to Excellence in Claims Handling at https://barryzalma.substack.com/welcome.
Write to Mr. Zalma at [email protected]; http://www.zalma.com; http://zalma.com/blog; daily articles are published at
Go to the podcast Zalma On Insurance at https://anchor.fm/barry-zalma; Follow Mr. Zalma on Twitter at https://twitter.com/bzalma; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://zalma.com/blog/insurance-claims-library/
Insurance Expert May Not Testify to Speculative and Contains Unsupported Conclusions.
Posted on September 18, 2026 by Barry Zalma
See the full video at and at https://rumble.com/v7fmifw-expert-may-only-testify-to-what-experience-supports.html
In Michele A. Over, and The Estate Of Paul R. Over v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, and State Farm Fire And Casualty Company, Civil Action No. 23-cv-02243-PAB-STV, United States District Court, D. Colorado (September 14, 2026) Michele and Paul Over sued State Farm Fire and State Farm Auto over hail-damage and stolen-vehicle claims.
The operative dispute concerned State Farm Auto’s motion to exclude or limit opinions from plaintiffs’ insurance-industry expert, Aaron Castillo. Castillo.
Law
The proponent of expert testimony must establish by a preponderance of the evidence that an expert is qualified and that the opinions are helpful, sufficiently grounded, and reliably derived and applied. Experience-based opinions must explain how the...
150 Months in Prison for Tax Fraud
Post 4846
Posted on September 17, 2026 by Barry Zalma
See the full video at https://lnkd.in/g8rh3JBX and https://lnkd.in/gmkdy-9C, In United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, Nos. 25-10609, 25-10611, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit (September 9, 2026) the Eleventh Circuit affirmed all challenged convictions, the 150-month aggregate sentence, and the challenged $4,123,474.55 restitution award.
FACTS
In United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, United States Of America v. Thomas Addaquay, Nos. 25-10609, 25-10611, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit (September 9, 2026) the Eleventh Circuit affirmed all challenged convictions, the 150-month aggregate sentence, and the challenged $4,123,474.55 restitution award.
FACTS
Thomas Addaquay controlled United Consolidated Accounting and Business Services (UC), nominally a check-cashing business.
The government proved a three-stage tax-refund scheme that converted the resulting refund checks into usable funds through ...
Major Fraud Perpetrator Asserts Fifth Amendment Privilege to Avoid Prosecution
Post 5489
Posted on September 14, 2026 by Barry Zalma
Fraudster Refuses to Answer Questions About His Alleged Fraud
See the full video at https://lnkd.in/gvicAMDr and at https://lnkd.in/gvicAMDr
In Great American Insurance Co. v. Gemstone Property Management, LLC, et al., No. 23-cv-9100 (LJL), United States District Court, S.D. New York (September 8, 2026) Great American Insurance Company alleged that it was defrauded through a scheme in which Subin Associates, LLP recruited individuals to stage construction-site injuries, arranged unnecessary medical treatment and litigation funding, and pursued fraudulent personal-injury claims.
Luis Manuel Garcia Salcedo, resulted in a $6 million settlement. Non-party Jose Hernandez allegedly worked as an assistant manager at Subin, operated Hernandez Associates, and owned litigation-funding companies that shared office space with Subin and provided services to its clients.
After Great American ...
Posted on November 20, 2026 by Barry Zalma
Probation Condition Must be Reasonably Directed at Curbing Future Criminality
Post 4584
While Probation Conditions Need Not Be Strictly Tied To The Precise Crime Committed, They Do Need To Be Reasonably Directed At Curbing The Defendant’s Future Criminality
In The People v. Nicolas Arpa, A174751, California Court of Appeals, First District, Third Division (November 19, 2026) Nicolas Arpa was charged in San Mateo County with five counts of insurance fraud, attempted grand theft by an employee or agent of $950 or more, grand theft by an employee or agent of $950 or more, and forgery.
He pled no contest to one count of insurance fraud (count 2) and to grand theft (count 5). His sentencing brief said he had suffered significant financial distress and felt remorse. It also said he no longer works in insurance and had made full restitution.
The trial court suspended the sentence and imposed two years of formal probation. One probation condition required him to abstain from using...
Dilatory, Obstructive Tactics Designed To Re-Open Proceedings And Vacate a Judgment Are Improper
Post 4583
In Three S Delaware, Inc. & Scott R. Steele v. Dataquick Information Systems, Inc. & Maxar Technologies, Inc., Civil Action No. 25-18991 (RK) (TJB), United States District Court, D. New Jersey (November 16, 2026) Three S Delaware (“3SD”) licensed real estate databases from a California company named DataQuick. A newly formed Delaware DataQuick bought the California DataQuick’s assets. The arbitrator later found that the sale included the 1996 license.
Delaware DataQuick sued 3SD in California. 3SD moved to compel arbitration and then counterclaimed. In May 2005, Steele and his counsel walked out of the merits hearing, and the arbitrator proceeded without them. He awarded about $6.17 million to DataQuick.
MARYLAND PROCEEDINGS:
The D. Md. (Judge Motz) confirmed the award, except for attorney’s fees. 3SD obtained a supersedeas bond of about $7.46 million from Federal Insurance Company. The Fourth Circuit affirmed in 2007.
Later ...
Insured’s Failure to Report Claim Before Expiration Defeats Claim
Post 4582
Posted on November 18, 2026 by Barry Zalma
In Diversified Restaurant Group, LLC, et al v. Houston Casualty Company, et al., No. 25-cv-02344-EMC, United States District Court, N.D. California (October 7, 2026) Diversified Restaurant Group and Golden Gate Bell (the “Insureds”) own or operate restaurants, including a Taco Bell in Antioch, California. Houston Casualty Company (HCC) issued them identical “claims made and reported” Employment Practices Liability (EPL) policies for 2022 and 2023. The 2022 policy ran from January 1, 2022 to January 1, 2023.
For the policy to apply, a covered claim had to be made during the policy period and reported to HCC within 30 days after it ended, which here was January 30, 2023. On about December 10, 2022, an underage employee reported alleged sexual misconduct.
On December 14, 2022, the employee’s counsel (Wilshire Law Firm) sent a letter to the Taco Bell. The letter referred to an “accident” on a stated date at a...