Suing for Unfair Competition and an Injunction to Avoid Private Limitation of Action Provision Dismissed
Barry Zalma
Jul 21, 2023
Read the full article at https://lnkd.in/gweU4EEp, see the full video at https://lnkd.in/gJJmw4zF and at https://lnkd.in/gRpzFsBu; and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4550 posts.
Katherine Rosenberg-Wohl had a homeowners insurance policy with State Farm Fire and Casualty Company (State Farm), providing coverage on her home in San Francisco. The policy has a limitation provision that requires lawsuits to be “started within one year after the date of loss or damage.”
In Katherine Rosenberg-Wohl v. State Farm Fire And Casualty Company, A163848, California Court of Appeals, First District, Second Division (July 11, 2023) she sought indemnity to remedy a defect in the home. State Farm refused to pay because there was no insurable event and because the suit was filed more than a year after the alleged loss.
FACTS
In late 2018 or early 2019, plaintiff noticed that on two occasions an elderly neighbor stumbled and fell as she descended plaintiff’s outside staircase and learned that the pitch of the stairs had changed and that to make the stairs safe the staircase needed to be replaced. In late April 2019, plaintiff authorized the work and contacted State Farm, and on August 9, she submitted a claim for the money she had spent.
The denial was based on the investigation findings and concluded there was no evidence of a covered cause for accidental direct physical damage to the property. The denial also stated that the policy does not provide coverage for preventative nor safety measures to the property. Maintenance would be the responsibility of the property owner to properly maintain the property to keep it safe.
Plaintiff submitted a claim to State Farm for her construction expenses, which by then were approximately $52,600, with another $16,800 in anticipated expenses for additional work. By letter dated August 26-plaintiff alleged, without any investigation-State Farm denied the claim. The letter also specifically referenced “the suit limitation period” as a “policy defense.”
Plaintiff filed two lawsuits against State Farm in San Francisco Superior Court. One alleged two causes of action for breach of the policy and for bad faith. That lawsuit was removed to federal court and was resolved against plaintiff on a motion to dismiss based on the one-year limitation provision. It is currently on appeal in the Ninth Circuit.
The second suit before the the Superior Court purports to allege a claim for violation of California’s unfair competition law. This case was also resolved against plaintiff, also based on the limitation provision, when the trial court sustained a demurrer to the second amended complaint without leave to amend. Plaintiff appealed.
On October 22, 2020-some 18 months after she had replaced the staircase, 14 months after State Farm had denied her claim the first time, and nearly six months after the one-year limitation period of the policy had expired-plaintiff filed two lawsuits in San Francisco County Superior Court.
On April 20, 2021, Judge Massullo sustained the demurrer with leave to amend to add additional facts supporting waiver. On May 21, plaintiff filed a second amended complaint (SAC), adding, apparently without leave of court, a claim for false advertising. The SAC then states, again in capitalized boldface, that “This Is Not A Lawsuit For Damages For Breach Of Contract; Rather It Is A Challenge To How State Farm Does Business.”
State Farm filed a demurrer and a motion to strike the SAC. On July 29, Judge Massullo entered her order sustaining the demurrer without leave to amend, a comprehensive order indeed, eight pages of thoughtful analysis. She held that “the Court is persuaded that Plaintiff’s claims are nonetheless ‘on the policy’ because they are ‘grounded upon [State Farm’s] failure to pay policy benefits.’” She also concluded that “[a]ll of the alleged acts which form the basis of Plaintiff’s claims occurred during the claim handling process.” Finally, Judge Massullo held that State Farm had not waived the limitation provision.
DISCUSSION
The one-year limitation provision in the State Farm policy is there because it was required by statute. [Califonria Insurance Code section 2071] The one-year limitation provisions have long been held valid as mandated by statute.
The One-Year Policy Limitation Provision Applies
State Farm asserted that “the Legislature has expressly endorsed the provision under Insurance Code section 2071” and argued that because the allegations here all concern how it handled plaintiff’s claim, the suit is subject to the policy limitation period under applicable law. In sum, the crux of plaintiff’s claim is grounded upon a failure to pay policy benefits.
An insured cannot plead around the one-year limitations provision by labeling her cause of action something different than breach of contract which, of course, includes claims for bad faith. Conduct by the insurer after the limitation period has run cannot, as a matter of law, amount to a waiver or estoppel.
The policy requires any waiver to be in writing. Plaintiff does not allege State Farm agreed to waive anything in writing. Therefore, the judgment was affirmed and State Farm was allowed to recover its costs on appeal.
ZALMA OPINION
The Court of Appeal spent many pages resolving this fairly simple dispute. The plaintiff sued to collect benefits she believed were owed under a policy of insurance only to find that the suit was filed to late. To avoid that problem she amended the suit to allege unfair business practices and sought an injunction, all of which were seen to be an alternative way to obtain policy benefits and failed again. For more than 120 years the California Supreme Court and Courts of Appeal have upheld the private limitation of action provision required by statute and no amount of creative pleading can avoid its effect.
(c) 2023 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to Excellence in Claims Handling at locals.com https://zalmaoninsurance.locals.com/subscribe.
Subscribe to my publications at substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/publish/post/107007808
Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01
Follow me on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/comm/mynetwork/discovery-see-all?usecase=PEOPLE_FOLLOWS&followMember=barry-zalma-esq-cfe-a6b5257
Go to the podcast Zalma On Insurance at https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/barry-zalma/support; Follow Mr. Zalma on Twitter at https://twitter.com/bzalma; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; https://creators.newsbreak.com/home/content/post; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://zalma.com/blog/insurance-claims-library. the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to Excellence in Claims Handling at locals.com https://lnkd.in/gfFKUaTf.
Subscribe to my publications at substack at https://lnkd.in/gcZKhG6g
Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gWVSBde.
Go to Newsbreak.com https://lnkd.in/g8azKc34
The Professional Claims Handler
Post 5218
Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/zalma-philosophy-claims-handling-part-8-barry-zalma-esq-cfe-zdwsc, see the full video at https://rumble.com/v70zl4s-the-zalma-philosophy-of-claims-handling-part-8.html and at https://youtu.be/MIYcF71ffRQ, and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 5200 posts.
Claims Commandment X – Thou Shall Not Pretend to be a Lawyer
Some experienced and professional claims people know the law in their area of expertise better than most lawyers.
Adjusters should be adjusters and leave lawyering to lawyers. Similarly, lawyers should be lawyers and never try to be adjusters.
Claims Commandment XI – Thou Shall Empathize With the Claimant
Everyone presenting a claim is unhappy, disturbed, shocked, injured and needs help.
Empathy is identification with and understanding of another’s situation, feelings, and motives. It is the ability to understand another person’s circumstances, point of view, thoughts, and feelings....
HOW TO CREATE AN EXCELLENCE IN CLAIMS HANDLING PROGRAM
See the full video at https://rumble.com/v70wb2i-the-zalma-philosophy-of-claims-handling-part-6.html and at https://youtu.be/tL5nDKPEs40 and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 5200 posts.
Post 5217
This is a change from my normal blog postings. It is my attempt. in more than one post, to explain the need for professional claims representatives who comply with the basic custom and practice of the insurance industry.
An Excellence in Claims Handling program begins with a statement in the insurer’s claims manual or statement of professionalism that it is dedicated to providing excellence in claims handling to every insured who presents a claim.
The excellence in claims handling program should include, at a minimum:
A series of lectures supported by text materials explaining:
A definition of insurance.
How to read and understand an insurance policy.
How to interview an insured, witness, or claimant.
How to assist an insured in the insured’s obligation to ...
The Professional Claims Handler
Post 5216
Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/zalma-philosophy-claims-handling-part-5-barry-zalma-esq-cfe-jde8c, see the full video at https://rumble.com/v70q4x8-the-zalma-philosophy-of-claims-handling-part-5.html and at https://youtu.be/6b9tZQsEkB4, and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 5200 posts.
This is a change from my normal blog postings. It is my attempt. in more than one post, to explain the need for professional claims representatives who comply with the basic custom and practice of the insurance industry.
Standards to be a Professional Claims Adjuster
The Insurance claims professional should be a person who:
1. Can read and understand the insurance policies issued by the insurer.
2. Understands the promises made by the policy.
3. Understand their obligation, as an insurer’s claims staff, to fulfill the promises made.
4. Are competent investigators.
5. Have empathy and recognize the difference between empathy and sympathy.
6. ...
The Professional Claims Handler
Post 5219
Posted on October 31, 2025 by Barry Zalma
An Insurance claims professionals should be a person who:
Can read and understand the insurance policies issued by the insurer.
Understands the promises made by the policy.
Understand their obligation, as an insurer’s claims staff, to fulfill the promises made.
Are competent investigators.
Have empathy and recognize the difference between empathy and sympathy.
Understand medicine relating to traumatic injuries and are sufficiently versed in tort law to deal with lawyers as equals.
Understand how to repair damage to real and personal property and the value of the repairs or the property.
Understand how to negotiate a fair and reasonable settlement with the insured that is fair and reasonable to both the insured and the insurer.
How to Create Claims Professionals
To avoid fraudulent claims, claims of breach of contract, bad faith, punitive damages, unresolved losses, and to make a profit, insurers ...
The History Behind the Creation of a Claims Handling Expert
The Insurance Industry Needs to Implement Excellence in Claims Handling or Fail
Post 5210
This is a change from my normal blog postings. It is my attempt. in more than one post, to explain the need for professional claims representatives who comply with the basic custom and practice of the insurance industry. This statement of my philosophy on claims handling starts with my history as a claims adjuster, insurance defense and coverage lawyer and insurance claims handling expert.
My Training to be an Insurance Claims Adjuster
When I was discharged from the US Army in 1967 I was hired as an insurance adjuster trainee by a professional and well respected insurance company. The insurer took a chance on me because I had been an Army Intelligence Investigator for my three years in the military and could use that training and experience to be a basis to become a professional insurance adjuster.
I was initially sat at a desk reading a text-book on insurance ...
The History Behind the Creation of a Claims Handling Expert
The Insurance Industry Needs to Implement Excellence in Claims Handling or Fail
Post 5210
This is a change from my normal blog postings. It is my attempt. in more than one post, to explain the need for professional claims representatives who comply with the basic custom and practice of the insurance industry. This statement of my philosophy on claims handling starts with my history as a claims adjuster, insurance defense and coverage lawyer and insurance claims handling expert.
My Training to be an Insurance Claims Adjuster
When I was discharged from the US Army in 1967 I was hired as an insurance adjuster trainee by a professional and well respected insurance company. The insurer took a chance on me because I had been an Army Intelligence Investigator for my three years in the military and could use that training and experience to be a basis to become a professional insurance adjuster.
I was initially sat at a desk reading a text-book on insurance ...
